Mandela, China and Godot
If I could have asked Mandela one question, it would have
been a simple one:
“How do you not hate?”
Imprisoned for decades on an island, but a white minority,
that would have fit right at home in Alabama circa 1962. Originally sentenced to death, Mandela, more
for his defiance of the “rule by minority” status of his society at the time,
Mandela wasn’t a violent person. He
didn’t kill anybody. Indeed, he was
more dangerous because he wanted justice, and was able to express such
sentiment in
terms more dangerous than that of a gun.
His ability to live such a long live was remarkable.
His ability to forgive and move on, when with the wave of a
hand, he could have incited the greatest slaughter, is worth mentioning. The more
the minority White Race realized the futility of it’s apartheid policies, the
more afraid they became of ending it. Letting
a caged lion you never fed out of it’s cage doesn’t seem to make a lot of
sense, and it took a chance with letting Mandela free.
Yet Mandela’s first reaction wasn’t to incite racial
division, or use hatred as a weapon to unite his people. His first actions were the opposite. There were no show trials. No purges.
Yes, people did pay the piper. But
it could’ve(should’ve?) been much, much worse.
Which brings me to China today, and Japan. I do not know how many jobs Japanese
factories create in China. I do know, as
I spend much of my time in Shenzhen, and Honda has a factory in Guangzhou, that
there are a lot of Honda’s here. All driven
by Chinese. My guess is that Japanese
factories create millions of jobs. Yet the
Chinese govt continues to create an atmosphere of tension towards Japan, that
quite frankly doesn’t give a shit. Politics
first, Jobs second. (You can do that when you don't have to run for election)
Is there a phrase in Chinese that means “let bygones be
bygones”? 过一天算一天?
I dunno. Yes, Japan
was very naughty, and very cruel, and viciously slaughtered millions of
Chinese.
I get that. So does everybody else. And if we are using numbers as a metric,
than this post fails miserably to properly compare Apartheid to Japan’s
oppression of the Chinese People.
I guess I should not expect to see any light at the end of
the tunnel here. The initial Opium War
was approx. 170 years ago. Still preaching it. Can’t let anyone forget. Blah, blah. Blah. If anything, it should be the British looking
themselves in the mirror for playing the role of drug dealer.
Kudo’s to the Chinese govt for letting it’s people know that
yes, they were indeed humiliated back then, and pretty much for a hundred years
up to 1949. Yet that’s also as much to
do with the failure, or lack of, Chinese institutions as well, isn’t it? Strong
civil societies with competent and modern officials just don’t let themselves
get put into these situations….consistently….over a hundred year period.
A mature, confident Chinese government would not mention the
ACT unless it also mentioned the REASON.
No, the reason isn’t that the barbarians were just mean, naughty
people. They saw a weakness, and evil
cads they were, exploited it. Until we
see an honest appraisal of Blame, however,
Until China looks in the mirror, and admits it still has some growing up
to do, nothing will change.
The sad
thing is we cannot take away China’s license.
All we can do is get out of the way, and hope it doesn’t swerve towards
us. China is our modern day
Godot. How long will we have to wait for
it to grow up, and move on?
There is an old Chinese saying as "冤冤相报何时了“, which means pretty much the same as “let bygones be bygones”. But it doesn't prevent CCP govt using hatred as part of a systematic brainwashing campaign to legitimise and sustain its ruling
ReplyDeleteI actually looked that up today at the factory, and it means "if revenge breeds revenge, will there ever be an end to it...:? (Thank you Pleco)...
ReplyDeleteI should've given you the full version of it, "冤冤相报何时了,得饶人处且饶人". Anyway, I understand your Chinese is pretty good and perhaps you can check Baidu's entry about it(http://baike.baidu.com/view/4305750.htm). Of course Baidu isn't much of a credible source, but you get the gist. By the way, I'm an overseas Chinese who enjoyed your blog tremendously nevertheless. Keep up the great work, will you?
Delete