The Glorious Motherland's Defeat of the Japanese Bandits!
By the time everyone reads this The Brave and Courageous
People’s Republic would have celebrated its victory over the Japanese Bandits.
Got that?
The contribution of The Motherland being both unrelenting
and unswerving.
Yes, you may claim the Glorious People’s Republic didn’t
kick Japan’s ass, and my reply would be “so what”? It did not defeat Japan? “Who cares”?
(Did the Japanese and PLA even share a
battlefield? )
And they want us all to go to China and celebrate!
Still…for the CCP to even hint at any sort of significant
contribution is awkward at best, and shows bad form.
This is my problem with the West: we are so polite and circumspect when
speaking with China that we simply cannot bring ourselves to embarrass this
Great and Ancient Place. We also feel “guilty”
to do so, in light of the millions of dead China suffered.
The sad truth is the 人民解放军 killed more Chinese than
it did Japanese, not that it will ever be a statistic the propaganda department
goes out of its way to share.
The Chinese Civil War produced nearly 2 million
casualties. All Chinese.
The War of Resistance with Japan had over a million dead
Chinese and half that number Japanese.
Slice it as you like, dice it as you see fit, the Chinese
themselves killed more of each other than they ever killed of Japanese.
Don’t you think about now everyone should be wondering when
China will just “let it go”? This is
more than a bad breakup, already. You’re
in a better place now….move on.
The Chinese People themselves will no doubt eagerly
celebrate the “defeat” of the Japanese Imperial Army. It will be a case study in “convenient historical
relapse”. Having the gall to hold such
a parade, however, is based more on propaganda to further unify The Peoples
Republic at the expense of both international respect(see above), and
History. All this simply puts China in even more of a
bad light.
And since when have the Chinese cared what we thought?
But revisionist history is what China does best. The Chinese know nothing of the Bataan Death March
(I’ve asked…they don’t), or of Tarawa, or Peleliu (nor do most of us, to be
honest), or Burma. They don’t understand
what it is like to withstand a night Japanese Banzai charge on
Guadalcanal. No one in China has ever
heard of Midway. (How many Chinese
carriers were there?)
So in essence, the Chinese are celebrating the victory of a
war that somebody else won.
Kinda like celebrating somebody else’s birthday party don’t
you think?
Those in the West, outside of China’s borders marvel at such
a thing. Seventy thousand troops on
display, missiles, tanks, guns…all very impressive…. if this was 1945. Sophisticated nations simply do not do this
type of thing anymore.
Is this the same group of guys in Beijing we have nothing to
worry about in the South China Sea?
Still, the parade will be broadcast, and I wonder exactly
what the broadcasters will say when VJ day comes around?
China, in essence is in a vacuum. The Chinese live in a shell amongst
themselves. Wondering what the outside
is like. They cannot invest in overseas
stocks. They cannot freely as they wish
even have foreign currency. Celebrating accomplishments within a context that
no one pays attention too. (ok, go open your children’s history books…does it
say China ‘defeated’ Japan?”) Ignorant
to the ridicule and disapproval of everyone else who isn’t Chinese and doesn’t
live within its borders.
This is perhaps the best example of one wanting his cake and
eating it, too: a victory you didn’t’
win and a celebration you really shouldn’t be having. You
can celebrate the end of the War. Fine. Just don’t celebrate a victory you had no
part in.
And still the irony of ironies persists: The Communist Party of China has killed more
Chinese than the Japanese Army ever did.
Will The Chinese People someday in the distant future celebrate the
demise of the Communist Party, too?
China celebrated the event with the Presidents of Sudan and Venezuela who of course were totally connected to the Pacific War against Japan.
ReplyDeleteFurther irony, how did a record number of Chinese celebrate their extra free long weekend...By flying to Japan to go shopping.....
I'm sure that other bulwark of Japanese Resistance Cuba was there as well.
ReplyDeleteChina wasn't on the attack outside its own borders, but it did a lot to bog down the Japanese army. So yes, there was a Chinese contribution to the victory over fascism. There are two or three problems. The biggest one is that the parade wasn't really about the past, but about the present tense and the future, as the "Economist" put it last month.
ReplyDeleteAnother is that the Chinese contribution may be overplayed. i agree with the author that for some reason, Westerners seem to feel obliged to be too "polite" to ask the right questions.
And still another, but that's a consequence from the first problem, is that it wasn't the PLA that fought that war. Much of what the CCP has "inherited" without comment is something China actually owes to KMT people.
Thank you, JR. Excellent comments all around. Unfortunately, when a country wishes to so publicly advertise its contribution as a NATION, critical analysis from others takes over. It would be fair to ask the question of the PLA, "where were you in 1945"?
ReplyDeleteNew article please! Chinese women and affectionate behavior. (Having souls)
ReplyDeletePractical love - (protecting your investment) vs actual innocent love
Ok, I hear you....getting tired of all this history stuff, eh?
ReplyDeleteI see you've expanded the range of your demands(!)
OK...the above will be my next post. I'll put everything on hold just for YOU.
Give me at least a week to put to paper....today's new post is 2200 words and took me more than a few days to complete.